Discussion Of The Importance Of Kashmir History Essay

One perceiver has noted, “ Since 1947, no U.S. disposal has recognized how important the India-Pakistan difference over Kashmir is to stableness in [ South Asia ] .

“ American involvements in South Asia tend to drop dramatically between periods of crisis, ” wrote Shirin Tahir-Kheli, a Bush disposal functionary. It seems that the U.S. ne’er paid near adequate attending to the importance of South Asia. Consecutive American disposals merely calculated that there were no major US strategic involvements at interest in the part, and the most Washington could make was to maintain the temperature down by brokering impermanent surceases of belligerencies, instead than step ining in the nucleus country of the Kashmir difference ( Rashid 109 ) . The part of Kashmir has been disputed over between India and Pakistan since 1947. After the onslaughts of 9/11, both authoritiess [ India and Pakistan ] believed that the war in Afghanistan would let them to settle their war for Kashmir. Kashmir is an of import district to Pakistan and India and at times has dictated their dealingss with one another and with the United States.

The disputed part of Kashmir portions its boundary lines with India, Pakistan, Afghanistan and China. However, approximately 45 % of the land is controlled by India, 35 % by Pakistan and a smaller 20 % by China, which was succeeded to China by Pakistan. China claims that they have every right to their part of Kashmir, Aksai Chin, because they claim that land is portion of Tibet, which is in turn portion of China. The bulk of the people within Kashmir live between the Himalayan Mountains and the Pir Panjal Mountains in the Kashmir Valley. The population of Kashmir consists of a big Muslim population, at approximately 70 % , and the staying 30 % are Hindu. Due to its location in the vale, Kashmir ‘s dirt is rich for farming. It produces maize, wheat, rice, Crocus sativus, fruits and other veggies.

Kashmir has two of import H2O supplies that flow through it. The first being the Indus River and the other is Jhelum. These organic structures of H2O both flow through Kashmir and into Pakistan and India. Both rivers are indispensable H2O supplies for both states, and the control of Kashmir gives control of the rivers. The competition of Kashmir started after the Indian Independence act of 1974, which divided India into two separate states ; India for the Hindus and Pakistan for the Muslim population.

The battle over Kashmir has chiefly been over who controls the land and who has claim to it. India believed it had a claim to Kashmir ; every bit good as Pakistan did. When the British left India after the Indian Independence Act of 1974, they ne’er finalized the position and truenesss of the 550 princely provinces within India. The Muslim population of the Kashmir Valley wanted to fall in Pakistan, but they were ruled by a Hindu, Maharaja Hari Singh ( Rashid pg. 110 ) . Although the Muslim population wanted them to fall in Pakistan, and the Hindu and Buddhist population wanted to fall in India, there were many other Kashmiris who wanted entire independency for their province. In September 1947, some Muslim Kashmiris rose in rebellion against the maharaja ‘s inability to make up one’s mind which side to fall in. Pakistan saw this as an chance and rapidly aided those take parting in the rebellion. The maharaja saw this as a menace and instantly asked New Delhi for military aid. In exchange for aid, the maharaja signed the accession papers to India with an understanding that Kashmirians would acquire to finally vote on their independency and Indian military personnels drove back the insurrectionists. A armistice was declared on January 1, 1949. Both sides held on to the parts of Kashmir they had acquired.

Both states [ India and Pakistan ] claimed the whole of Kashmir, non merely the districts they had acquired. India claimed a right to Kashmir based on the accession paperss signed by the maharaja and Pakistan based its claim on the UN Security Council declarations in 1948, which stated that Kashmiris had a right to make up one’s mind whether they wanted to fall in India or Pakistan. Since Kashmir had a larger Muslim population, Pakistan automatically assumed that Kashmir would desire to side with them.

Every clip there has been a battle, an rebellion or insurgence against India within Kashmir, Pakistan was speedy to endorse them. Seizing the chance to weaken India, the ISI encouraged immature Kashmiris to come to Pakistan for preparation. The ISI foremost trained secular and nationalist Kashmiri groups, but rapidly switched its support to Kashmiri Islamic groups, who were linked to Pakistan ‘s ain Islamic parties ( Rashid pg. 111 ) . The ISI finally shifted many of the Kashmiri preparation cantonments to Taliban-controlled Afghanistan. Aside from the insurgence, the Kashmiri population held several public protests in response to the policies and tactics adopted by the Indians. These tactics included the violent death of civilians in reprisal onslaughts, extrajudicial violent deaths, anguish of captives, and the systematic usage of colza as a arm of panic by Indian soldiers ( Rashid pg. 112 ) .

The Kashmir struggle has brought negative attending to India, every bit good as Pakistan. It has at times harmed dealingss with the U.S. and stopped from any type of dealingss being built between India and Pakistan. The Pakistani ground forces carefully calculated the sorts of arms and financess it provided the Kashmiri activists. The degree of support was kept merely below what India might utilize to warrant an onslaught on Pakistan. This degree of support besides prevented Western authoritiess from coming down excessively difficult on Pakistan.

India and Pakistan have gone to war three different occasions over Kashmir. Their dealingss have ever hung by a thin line. What made this struggle unsafe for everyone was that both states had tested atomic arms and were capable of establishing. Whether they would utilize the arms was another inquiry.

The Indian Airlines commandeering caused dealingss between India and Pakistan to plump to a perilously low degrees. The highjacking made India even more determined to penalize Pakistan. However, India failed to have support from the United States for any onslaught.

In the 2000 presidential elections, India welcomed a Republican triumph, trusting for a displacement in U.S policy towards Pakistan. The incoming Bush disposal was acute to befriend India, but more in order to enlist it as a spouse in the strategic containment of China than to penalize Pakistan ( Rashid pg. 115 ) . Trying to derive U.S. support, India ‘s premier curate, Minister Vajpayee, invited Musharraf for negotiations. Musharraf interpreted this offer as a mark of failing from India as a response to the stepped up onslaughts by the activists. Vajpayee besides underestimated Musharraf and as a consequence, the three twenty-four hours acme was a failure.

After 9/11, the United States was set on a planetary war against terrorist act, a war against al Qaeda and the Taliban. They knew that the ISI had preparation installations within Pakistan and their boundary line along Afghanistan. The United States was speedy to enlist Pakistan as an ally. This offended India greatly. After 9/11, India saw this as an chance to carry the United States to declare Pakistan a province patron of terrorist act.

Following the Indian Independence, the relationship between the United States and India was that of misgiving towards each other. During the Cold War, India attempted to aline itself with the Soviet Union in response to Washington ‘s support for Pakistan and China. The United States aligned itself with Pakistan as a manner to assist incorporate Soviet-friendly India and to utilize Pakistan in Afghanistan against the Soviet business at the clip.

After the Cold War and the autumn of the Soviet Union, it freed India to prosecute relationships with all the great powers, particularly the United States. At the start of 1990s, India realized that its dealingss with the United States, China, Japan and Europe were all developing ; and India rapidly moved to mend the state of affairs ( Mohan pg 155 ) . After the onslaughts of 9/11, Indian intelligence bureaus provided the U.S. with information on Al Qaeda and related groups ‘ activities within Pakistan and Afghanistan. India ‘s part to the “ War on Terrorism ” has helped construct India ‘s dealingss with several states, including the U.S. and Europe. Under President G.W. Bush, many of the countenances that were imposed under the Clinton Administration after India ‘s testing of atomic arms were lifted.

One of Pakistan ‘s largest national security concerns is the regulation of Kashmir. Pakistan believes that they have a claim over Kashmir because it is preponderantly Muslim and besides because a UN Security Council declarations in 1948, which stated that Kashmiris had a right to make up one’s mind whether they wanted to fall in India or Pakistan. Because the Indus River starts in Kashmir, flows through Pakistan so into India, it is the chief H2O supply to Pakistan ; Pakistan fears that if control of this river falls into Indian custodies, that they would construct dikes and reroute the flow of H2O, turning Pakistan into a sweet. The Pakistani intelligence bureau, ISI, has helped train and supply activists within Kashmir, to contend against India ‘s regulation.

When the ISI was back uping Kashmiri Islamic groups, they drew their inspiration from the Muslim Brotherhood and described their battle as an Islamic war of national release, but non as a jehad ( Rashid, pg. 111 ) . Then the ISI switched their support to the Pakistani and Kashmiri extremist groups belonging to the Deobandi religious order of Sunni Islam, which believed in a jehad to get the better of India and “ Islamize ” Kashmir. It was at this clip that the ISI switched their support in Afghanistan to the Taliban. This determination was non based on spiritual ground, but on the fact that these groups were more utmost in demoing their hatred for India and more willing to assist the ISI. The ISI shortly shifted many of the Kashmiri preparation cantonments to Taliban-controlled Afghanistan ( Rashid, pg. 111 ) .

The ISI had helped put up different activist groups to contend against India. Harkat ul-Ansar had been set up with ISI support in the mid-1990s as a periphery activist group primed to transport out dramatic Acts of the Apostless of terrorist act ( Rashid pg. 112 ) . The group carried out several violent deaths and snatchs of Westerns in Indian Kashmir, and the United States declared it a terrorist group. The group so changed its name to Harkat ul-Mujahedin, and became a cardinal allyof the Taliban and al Qaeda, assisting run developing cantonments in Afghanistan for Kashmiri activists ( Rashid pg. 112 ) .

After 9/11, the U.S. was speedy to aline itself with Pakistan. Although there was misgiving of the ISI, the U.S. came to the decision that it had no pick but to utilize the ISI in intelligence assemblage because Pakistan shared the longest boundary line with Afghanistan. The Pakistani ground forces ne’er understood what was obvious to broad Pakistanis, that after 9/11, the international community would hold zero tolerance for Islamic extremism and that the ISI ‘s backup of hawkish groups would hold to discontinue, non merely in Afghanistan, but besides in Kashmir ( Rashid pg. 115 ) . There was echt hope that the ground forces would hold no pick but to interrupt its link with the extremists, fight extremism, and prevent Al Qaeda from utilizing Pakistan as a base.

The military and the ISI thought otherwise. They believed that alternatively of assisting the U.S. overthrow the Taliban government, they would shrive it of harnessing in the Kashmiri activists. Pakistan believed that because it was now allied with the United States and because the United States was so dependent on Pakistan for the war in Afghanistan, they [ Pakistani military ] believed that they could coerce India to the negociating tabular array by stepping up onslaughts. This did n’t assist ease any tenseness between the two states. After a monolithic auto bomb exploded outside the Kashmir parliament constructing killing 29 people, Indian leaders responded in an tumult, faulting Pakistan for the bombardment. Attacks continued until five activists shot their manner into the Indian parliament in New Delhi, killing 14 people. This left India outraged, and instantly began large-scale troop motion to the Pakistani boundary line. Both states began strategic war games, fixing itself for all out war. The U.S. became concerned because if Pakistan and India were to travel to war that would intend all U.S. forces would hold to be evacuated from U.S. bases inside Pakistan. President Bush delivered an ultimatum to Pakistan stating if Pakistan wished to stay an ally to the U.S. , that they would follow. Musharaf complied with the ultimatum and in his address he condemned terrorist act in all its signifiers and said that Pakistan would non let its districts to be used for any terrorist activities and that “ no organisation will be allowed to indulge in terrorist act in the name of Kashmir ( Rashid pg. 117 ) . ”

Advancement on the declaration over Kashmir would liberate India ‘s political and diplomatic energies so that the state could play a larger function in universe political relations. It would besides let go of India ‘s armed forces from territorial defence, leting them to acquire more involved in peace and stableness operations around the Indian Ocean ( Mohan pg. 155 ) . In the terminal, as India tries to set up itself as a universe power, the issues of Kashmir do n’t look to be as of import. India wants to keep a balance of power within South Asia. When it comes to China, forestalling China from deriving inordinate influence in India ‘s immediate vicinity and viing with Beijing in Southeast Asia are still among the more abiding elements of India ‘s foreign policy ( Rashid pg. 158 ) . U.S support is necessary for India ‘s rise as a new universe power to be successful, and there is no denying that India will hold more in common with the United States than any other great power in the hereafter.